“I’m Not Going”: Mesa v. O’Connor and When Teens Control Parenting Time

Parenting Time
Articles, Family Law

Mesa v. O’Connor takes on a question that shows up in a lot of high-conflict custody cases with an older teen: when is it better for the court to stop forcing parenting time and accept that an older child’s “I’m not going” has real legal weight?  In this post-decree dispute, the family court was dealing with a long history of conflict, a teenage child, and intense disagreement over the child’s healthcare, including the child’s gender transition.  See Mesa v. O’Connor, 259 Ariz. 203 (Ariz. App. 2025), review denied and ordered depublished, 547 P.3d 231 (Ariz. 2025).  After an evidentiary hearing, the family court judge awarded Mother sole legal decision-making and, instead of creating a schedule for Father, ordered that any parenting time would occur only if and when the teen chose it, supported by reunification-focused services.

Escalating conflict over the teen’s care led to both parents filing competing petitions to modify legal decision-making and parenting time, which the family court consolidated for a contested evidentiary hearing.  Each side put on testimony about the child’s history, the state of the parent-child relationships, and the likely impact of forcing or not forcing contact.  When the family court then entered final orders giving Mother sole legal decision-making authority, leaving Father with no set parenting time schedule, conditioning any contact on the teen’s choice, and later appointing a therapeutic interventionist after those final orders, Father appealed and challenged both the child-driven structure and the late TI appointment.

On appeal, Father argued that the court had let the child decide his parental rights.  The Court of Appeals rejected that framing and focused on the process.  The Court emphasized that the family court judge still did the full best interests analysis required under A.R.S. § 25-403, made detailed findings on the record, and then concluded that, for this almost-adult teen (age 16 at the time of the trial), forced contact with Father risked more harm than benefit.  The family court judge had relied on the child’s age, maturity, and firm refusal to see Father as key evidence in deciding what was best. But the judge—not the child—still made the legal decision about parenting time.

The Court of Appeals held: “a superior court may order parenting time at the child’s discretion after analyzing the child’s best interests.  In this case, the superior court considered the statutory best interest factors and did not abuse its discretion by concluding that Father should have no parenting time without the child’s consent.”  See id. at ¶ 2.  

In plain terms, the case stands for this idea: a judge cannot just shrug and say, “whatever the kid wants,” but can decide that the healthiest order in a particular case is one where the door to parenting time is open and the teen controls whether to walk through it.

The Court of Appeals did, however, rein in the family court on the professional appointment piece.  The Court struck the post-judgment therapeutic interventionist order, holding that the family court lacked statutory authority to add a new TI obligation under A.R.S. § 25-405 after final legal decision-making and parenting-time orders were already in place.  That portion is a pointed reminder that creative solutions in family court must still fit within the statutes.

Procedurally, Mesa v. O’Connor has one last twist.  The decision was issued as a published Division One opinion on January 28, 2025, which initially gave it precedential force.  Then, on August 19, 2025, the Arizona Supreme Court denied review and ordered the opinion depublished, without explanation.  Mesa is no longer binding law and should not be cited as controlling precedent, but its reasoning can still guide how lawyers think about older teen, high-conflict cases—highlighting the teen’s maturity, the steadiness of the child’s wishes, the potential harm of forced contact, and the importance of a clear, on-the-record best interests ruling before a court effectively lets the child control parenting time.

Previous Post
“The Two Become One”: What Arizona’s Community Property Rules Are Really About